What makes an AI chat private?
Four things decide it: whether you need an account, whether the conversation is written to a log, whether the text is used for training, and how long anything is kept. A service can be strict on 1 of those and loose on the rest, so the word private on its own tells you nothing.
Almost every assistant now calls itself private somewhere on the page. The word covers four separate questions. A service can answer one of them well and answer the other three badly, so reading the four apart is the whole difference between a claim and a fact.
On this page
The account is the first question
An account is what turns a pile of separate questions into one profile. Without an account there is no key to file the conversation under, so yesterday's questions cannot be attached to today's. With an account every conversation joins the same record, and that record usually outlives the conversation. This is the part people skip, because signing in feels like a formality rather than a decision about data.
Logs are separate from the conversation
A chat can disappear from your screen and stay on a server. Two different things get stored: the conversation itself, and the server access log that records who connected and when. A service can delete the first and keep the second for months. When a page says nothing is stored, it is worth knowing which of the two it means.
Training is a third question, and it is not the same as storage
Storing a conversation and training a model on a conversation are different operations with different consequences. Deleted text can still have shaped a model that was trained before the deletion. Some services train by default and offer an opt-out in settings; others do not train on user text at all. The setting matters more than the promise, because the setting is the thing that runs.
Retention is the number that makes the rest real
The three questions above all end in the same question: how long. A service that keeps logs for 24 hours and a service that keeps logs for 2 years can both say they keep logs. The number is what tells you which one you are using, and a service that will not name a number has effectively named a long period.
Questions about private AI
Is a private mode the same as a private service?
No. A private mode usually stops the conversation from appearing in your own history. The server side is a separate matter, and the mode says nothing about it.
Does paying make a chat more private?
Sometimes, and it is worth checking rather than assuming. Some services stop training on paid accounts and keep the same retention. Paying also creates a billing record, which is a stronger identifier than an email address.
Can I verify any of this myself?
Partly. You can verify that a service does not ask for an account and that a conversation does not survive a closed tab. Retention on the server is a claim you have to read rather than test.
Open a chat that asks for no account and see what is left to check.
Open private chat